I personally didn’t feel as strongly toward Gluttony as I did toward Greed in terms of feeling like the sin was being fully utilized. Yeah, you want to get as much food for the pig as you can, but the pig seems to represent the gluttony of 47’s clients, rather than himself, and other than completing the challenges, I didn’t feel encouraged to feed the pig anything extra simply for the sake of giving it more food.
I still rank Greed at number one, solely in terms of its sin being fully utilized, in the fact that it is purely 47’s own greed, and it influenced my own, as I took the maddeningly difficult path each time in order to collect all the coins, not just for the challenge, but because I really wanted to have them all and not give any to the frog for extra weapons.
Ranking behind that, I’d put Pride and Envy as tied in terms of representing their sins. Third would be Gluttony, and Sloth and Lust tied for fourth place, as I really can’t understand how their sins are meant to be applied.
Now, as far as enjoyable gameplay, I’ll admit that Greed ranks dead last, as you have to be obsessive to fully represent the sin and that saps away the enjoyment. Pride is a bit better in that you do feel proud in doing it properly, but there’s no real reward beyond that and it doesn’t really have a special gimmick. Sloth was just irritating, but at least engaging enough. Lust was certainly entertaining with its twist, but maddening in how many points there were for something to go wrong. Gluttony was more of a blend of Greed and Pride’s gameplays that was perfected to be more enjoyable. In terms of most enjoyable gameplay, I’m loving Envy immensely. Irritating when something goes wrong, but it gets the blood pumping in an exciting way, not just an angry way, and I think that’s the competition factor.
It all depends on what respect you rank each sin, really. In terms of style and utilization of sin, I’ve got Greed up front, but dead last on gameplay, with Envy taking the top spot for that. And most enjoyable changes to the map? Lust takes the prize for that one.